The bill aims to trial drug testing for new income support recipients at three sites: Adult applicants who fail their drug tests are referred to drug treatment, although their children can still receive benefits.
But come from a disadvantaged background or be on income support, and you're a deadbeat, a bludger, deserving little or no sympathy. In these six states, a total of of those tested produced positive results, or 0.
I thoroughly respect and understand the opinion of the other side, that welfare recipients should not be subjugated to drug tests. The Court held that regardless of how noble the intention of the policy, the City did not prove that the consent to the urine test was obtained validly.
Applying the evidence from the drug courts to the drug testing of welfare recipients "completely misrepresents the situation".
She added that results of a drug test did not necessarily indicate a person's capacity for work. They would have responded to approach after approach from organisations like ours, which have offered to help redesign their policy to achieve their aims without stigmatising vulnerable people.
When one first hears about the idea of testing welfare recipients to make sure that they are not using drugs, the idea seems to be sound. State officials say that Medicaid would cover the costs of those drug treatment programs.
Drug Testing For Welfare Recipients: Petula Dvorak of the Washington Post commented: Unlike people within the criminal justice system, who were given a choice of treatment or jail, people participating in the trial would have to either agree to drug testing and treatment or have their welfare benefits cut.
Let me know what you think Presumed Problem There is a belief among some that welfare recipients will spend their welfare payments on drugs instead of food, medicine, clothing, and the like.
The rise of ice and the changing face of Australian drug use Furthermore, it says drug testing cannot be used to determine substance abuse or dependence; it could undermine an unemployed person's relationship with their case manager, and be very expensive.
The results are inconclusive. The pro-welfare drug testing meme reproduced above appears to present a reasonable approach to many viewers, who reason: Then, of the 43 organisations which raised the drug testing bill in their submissionsall 43 strongly opposed it.
Was the Problem Real. Is there evidence that mandatory drug testing of welfare recipients can help drug users get off welfare. Because the proposed trial would be compulsory for welfare recipients, and have the potential to increase poverty, as well as lead to other adverse outcomes, there was a greater level of accountability required of the Government.
Based upon the figures shown below, several states count only the money spent on actual drug testing in the cost of their programs. The problem for proponents is that the programs keep failing — in practice, in the courts, or both.
Summary of H.R - th Congress (): Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Act. The primary reason contenders for drug-testing recipients is welfare programs do require their users to be drug-free, which needs to be enforced.
Some companies require drug testing for employment, and failing a drug test will often result in termination. What 7 states discovered after spending more than $1 million drug testing welfare recipients What a waste. Dec 11, · The Michigan Senate passed a bill Wednesday that would require welfare recipients undergo drug testing.
If welfare recipients refuse to be tested, they would lose benefits for at. INTRODUCTION: There is an ongoing debate on whether drug testing of welfare recipients is legal in many of the local state governments.
Welfare is suppose to meet the basic needs and drugs are far from the basic human needs. Some states are considering legislation to require welfare recipients and those that receive public assistance to submit to drug tests and testing.Drug testing welfare recipients